Iowa Banking Law Blog

Phishing for answers: Customer claims bank to blame for fraud scheme
Mar. 31, 2010Mary A. Zambreno, Iowa Banking Law Blog
Phishing for answers: Customer claims bank to blame for fraud scheme

A complaint filed in December 2009 by a Michigan-based company alleges that its bank’s conduct caused the company to become the target and victim of a phishing attack.

Dallas-based Comerica is being sued by its customer, Experi-Metal Inc., who alleges that for a period of eight years, the bank sent emails to its customers instructing them to click on a link in the email to renew Comerica’s digital certificate.  In 2008, the bank changed its security methods entirely, switching instead to tokens that would generate a random set of numbers to be entered with the customer’s user name and password.  In 2009, however, a phishing email was sent to Experi-Metal claiming to be from Comerica that gave instructions to open a link in the email.  Upon clicking the link, the Experi-Metal employee logged on to what looked to be the Comerica website.  Instead, hackers made 47 wire transfers to the tune of almost $550,000.  The bank counters that a reasonably alert person would have caught on that the email was a phishing scam. 

To read more about the Experi-Metal Inc. vs. Comerica case, see this Bank Info Security article.

The moral of this story?  If you are a bank, consider implementing policies prohibiting your institution from sending your customers emails that request personal information.  If you are a bank customer, do not open emails that purport to be from your bank without first contacting your bank to confirm that the email you received is legitimate.

share this page:
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
Industry Categories: Banks & Financial Institutions

Mary A. Zambreno




Latest Articles

Hell hath no fury: A brief history of the Alienation of Affection Tort in Iowa

Professional golfer John Daly finalized his divorce from his fourth ex-wife, Sherrie Miller in 2010, […]

5 ways that celebrity divorces are not like yours

#5 – Your vitriolic voicemails don’t get published in the media.  When Denise Richards and […]

Ensuring smooth post-separation transfer by circumventing the ability-to-repay rule

(Co-authored with Samantha Wagner) The CFPB recently took action to ensure successors of mortgages (such […]