Iowa Banking Law Blog

New court ruling provides amplification of banks’ data security responsibilities
Aug. 29, 2012L. Allyn Dixon Jr., Iowa Banking Law Blog
Target data security breach

In a case with a result similar to the recent Patco case, where a court held that a bank’s security measures were not commercially reasonable and reversed a lower court’s decision to dismiss the claim against the bank involved, a U.S. District Court in Mississippi has dismissed Bancorp South’s countersuit against Choice Escrow and Land Title. Bancorp South claimed the title company, not Bancorp South’s subsidiary bank, was responsible for a $400,000 fraudulent wire transfer. The case is likely to now go to trial. Essentially, the court ruled that UCC 4A, which governs electronic funds transfers, pre-empts contractual indemnification clauses that contradict the spirit of the UCC. The company involved had opted out of the $14 billion bank’s dual control options, which the bank believed should lead to losses being the responsibility of its customer.

This ruling highlights the need to ensure that a financial institution’s security procedures are indeed commercially reasonable, because contract language that provides for indemnification and an acknowledgment by a customer that they are reasonable may not be enough to satisfy a court.


share this page:
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
Categories: Allyn Dixon, Banking Law
Industry Categories: Banks & Financial Institutions
Practice Area Categories: Banking Law

L. Allyn Dixon Jr.




Latest Articles

New “Know Your Vendor” Guidance from the OCC

In a recent Bulletin, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency published new guidance […]

Delay Announced for Key Affordable Healthcare Act Provisions

Yesterday afternoon, the Treasury Department announced that employers with more than 50 full time equivalent […]

Against this background . . .

In recent months, we’ve noticed a substantial increase in the number of Section 19 waiver […]